Paragraph 201

Likewise, in the verse concerning the “Spirit,” He saith: “And they will ask Thee of the Spirit. Say, ‘the Spirit proceedeth at My Lord’s command.’” As soon as Muḥammad’s answer was given, they all clamorously protested, saying: “Lo! an ignorant man who knoweth not what the Spirit is, calleth Himself the Revealer of divine Knowledge!” And now behold the divines of the age who, because of their being honored by His name, and finding that their fathers have acknowledged His Revelation, have blindly submitted to His truth. Observe, were this people today to receive such answers in reply to such questionings, they would unhesitatingly reject and denounce them—nay, they would again utter the selfsame cavils, even as they have uttered them in this day. All this, notwithstanding the fact that these Essences of being are immensely exalted above such fanciful images, and are immeasurably glorified beyond all these vain sayings and above the comprehension of every understanding heart. Their so-called learning, when compared with that Knowledge, is utter falsehood, and all their understanding naught but blatant error. Nay, whatsoever proceedeth from these Mines of divine Wisdom and these Treasuries of eternal knowledge is truth, and naught else but the truth. The saying: “Knowledge is one point, which the foolish have multiplied” is a proof of Our argument, and the tradition: “Knowledge is a light which God sheddeth into the heart of whomsoever He willeth” a confirmation of Our statement.

On to paragraph eleven of the twenty-two that look at those two stations that the Manifestations of God occupy. Baha'u'llah is still looking at the theme of rejecting the truth based on one's own desires.

Why is He addressing this theme here? How does it fit in with His overall argument?

In these paragraphs He is talking about the twin stations of the Manifestations of God, and the argument could be made that He is no longer talking about that. No problem. But for us, this all fits under that category. Every single Manifestation has had to face the problem of giving a truthful answer to the questions of the religious leaders of the day, only to be accused of ignorance or insanity. This is part of their absolute unity. But they have all had to face it in their own way, in their own time. This is part of their differences based on when and where they lived.

We think Baha'u'llah is talking about this here because it is relevant to where the uncle of the Bab is about to be. In just a few paragraphs He will begin His actual defence of the Bab, giving proofs of His mission from the the Qur'an, a demonstration of His efficacy through His followers, and finally from the Bab's own life. It would be so easy to deny any of these if we were caught up in the snare of egotism, so it seems fitting that He is giving us this final warning before reminding us of the necessary positive qualities of the true seeker, and then moving on to His argument.

In terms of Muhammad's response to the question about the spirit, we can see now that He gave a truthful answer about a subject we can never really understand. The spirit does come from God's command. No Muslim would deny this. But at the time, it probably seemed like a non-answer, and went against the common understanding, which was obviously flawed. So rather than explore the response, the people of the day just denied Muhammad.

We know that there were many similar instances where the authorities denounced the Bab based on similar responses.

By reminding the uncle of this, Baha'u'llah is encouraging him to really consider any and all responses, regardless of his immediate reaction to it. He is pointing out to him the importance of not presuming that we have knowledge and everyone else must agree with us. We are not the final authority, the standard by which we must judge all else. He said this way back in paragraph 2 when He cautioned us not to "regard the words and deeds of mortal men as a standard". This includes ourselves. We must always be fair-minded.

The last two quotes in this paragraph are a good reminder that there is only one truth in the universe, no matter how we may try to break it down to smaller, more easily understood bits. And that this light we call knowledge is, in the end, given to us by God's good will.

Finally, this all hearkens back to paragraph 6 where He tells us "the more closely you observe the denials... the firmer will be your faith..." As we recall this particular denial, it is hoped that we will avoid offering up the exact same objection.